NEWNow you can listen to Fox News articles!
As testimony in the Carmelo Anthony murder trial resumes Monday, one Texas attorney says the case may be less about the fatal collision itself and more about how jurors interpret questions of self-defense, race, any prior connections between the youths and even the unique culture of a high school track meet.
Anthony, who is accused of stabbing student Austin Metcalf to death during an argument in Texas last year, has pleaded not guilty and claims he was acting in self-defense. The high-profile case began last week amid public scrutiny and debate about the case.
Prosecutors adjourned their case on Saturday after calling 21 witnesses. Anthony's defense made a motion to dismiss, but the judge denied the motion. His team called three witnesses on Saturday, and testimony will resume on Monday.
Larry Taylor, a former Texas prosecutor and longtime criminal defense attorney, told Fox News Digital that jurors will be tasked with evaluating much more than physical evidence.
KARMELO ANTHONY'S KILLING WITNESSES CONFIRMED AUSTIN METCALF'S STATEMENTS IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE ATTACK.
Defense attorney Mike Howard delivers opening statements during Carmelo Anthony's murder trial in the Collin County District Court. (Pat Lopez)
“When it comes to an issue like this, I'm sure the young men are looking, okay, what was the situation like? Was he really in danger? Was he really afraid? Why did he have a knife? Why didn't he get up and leave?” Taylor said.
Taylor noted that Texas immunity laws could be a critical factor in the trial.
“Did Karmelo really have a duty or obligation to retreat if attacked?” he said. “It's happening in Texas. Isn't that a private state?”
KARMELO ANTHONY'S SELF-DEFENSE PLEA MAY EXPLAIN ATTEMPTED MURDER IN HIGH SCHOOL HISTORY MEETS STABBING: ANALYST
The lawyer also suggested that race could be an inevitable topic during the trial, especially if there is a heated public debate about the case.
🔎 Do you know something we should investigate?
📩 Send story tips to [email protected]
📸 Share photos on Instagram: @fndstepprice
🎥 Submit interesting video and breaking news to X: @Stephenyprice
🗞️ Your knowledge can help reveal the next big story.
“We would be fooling ourselves if we said that certain areas of our region or certain cities are not easy to work … especially if there is polarization of black and white,” said Taylor.
Taylor also predicted that the jury selection — which does not include Black jurors — could face scrutiny if the defense believes Black jurors were unfairly excluded from the panel, potentially halting future appeal challenges.
AMERICA CAN'T PUT DOWN THE RACE CARD. AND IT IS A SHAME ON OUR NATION
Carmelo Anthony, 17, has been arrested and charged with the stabbing death of Texas star Austin Metcalf. (FOX 4)
Beyond the legal arguments, Taylor said the judges may need to be educated on something more basic: how a high school track meet actually works.
A longtime coach who participated in the sport in college, Taylor pushed back against suggestions that athletes from rival schools could not get to know each other or interact regularly.
KARMELO ANTHONY DEFENSE, PROSECUTORS LEAD VISIBLE FIRST BATTLE AS EMOTIONS RISE OPENING SCENE: EXPERT
Carmelo Anthony is accused of stabbing and killing Austin Metcalf during a rally in Frisco, Texas, on April 2, 2025. (FOX4; Jeff Metcalf)
“I've been coaching track for 30 years. I ran in college and it's normal for people to develop relationships with people from other schools that they compete against,” he said.
According to Taylor, understanding that dynamic could be important if prosecutors want to determine whether Anthony and the Metcalf brothers had a previous relationship before the fatal encounter. Taylor said the track meet usually takes hours, with athletes from different schools spending significant time running around each other throughout the day.
SURVEILLANCE VIDEO SHOWS BAD KILLING OF AUSTIN METCALF AT TEXAS TRACK MEET, ADULTS SAY
“I think four or five judges, if not more, don't know what's going on in the meeting,” Taylor said.
GOT ADVICE?
Taylor also dismissed allegations that athletes from competing schools would have little reason to know each other, saying friendships and familiarity on teams are common.
He also suggested that allegations about past dealings between Anthony and the Metcalf brothers could be relevant if presented at trial. Allegations that Anthony had been molested in the past, which have become public but disputed, could bolster the defense's case if supported by evidence, he said.
FOLLOW US ON X
Another question that may be considered by the judges is why Anthony allegedly had a knife at the song meeting. Taylor said this issue cannot be taken lightly and will require an explanation from the defense.
GET NEWS VIA EMAIL
“That will have to be explained to this group,” he said.
KARMELO ANTHONY'S FAMILY PLANS $500K IN DONATIONS AFTER FACED BY FINANCIAL EXECUTIVE STAB
Courtroom footage shows prosecutors presenting opening statements in the murder case of Carmelo Anthony at the Collin County Courthouse in McKinney, Texas. (Pat Lopez)
Taylor noted that athletes sometimes carry small knives or tools to cut athletic tape, work on equipment or carry track spikes, though he stressed that Anthony's exact reason for having the knife would need to be established by evidence and proof.
CLICK HERE FOR MORE NEWS
The lawyer also pushed back against criticism of the fundraising efforts for Anthony's legal defense. Although supporters of the defendant have raised large sums through online fundraising platforms, Taylor argued that mounting a strong defense in such a sensitive case requires significant resources.
“He's literally fighting for his life,” Taylor said, noting that expert witnesses, investigators and trial preparation can quickly become expensive.
CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS PROGRAM
As both sides prepare for another week of testimony, Taylor believes the case remains difficult to predict.
“A box of chocolates,” she said. “You're never sure what you're going to get.”
